like:

pee-wee's big adventure
beetlejuice
batman
batman returns
ed wood
sweeney todd

hate:

edward scissorhands
the nightmare before christmas
mars attacks
sleepy hollow
planet of the apes
big fish
charlie and the chocolate factory
corpse bride

if i've forgotten anything, i probably hated it.

now you.

there's a film forum.
basically old tim burton=love. new tim burton=meh.

yeah sorry about that. i thought i was posting in the film forum.

I'll say yes to edward scissorhands, big fish, and beetlejuice. The rest I either don't care about, haven't seen or didn't like.

__________________
"Hey Ram, doesn't this cafeteria have a no-fags-allowed rule?"

i think i like all of his stuff but i'd say that some are more watchable over and over again than others. Beetlejuice is one of my favourite films of all time and i've seen it god knows how many times, so that's number one obviously.

i absolutely adore Sleepy Hollow and Batman Returns, both of which i've seen about a million times each, but i could take or leave Batman. I think i found Jack Nicholson a little too frightening, even when i watch it now.
I remember liking Pee Wee's Big Adventure a lot, though it's been at least ten years since i last saw it. i'd quite like it on DVD actually. Ed Wood is pretty good but i don't think it would be half as good if Johnny Depp wasn't in it. Big Fish and Edward Scissorhands make me too upset to watch again even though i love them. i think i would love Nightmare Before Christmas if i had seen it as a child but as it is i only think it's good, not great. Planet of the Apes was kind of meh, as was Corpse Bride. Mars Attacks was shite, pretty much.

so basically:

love
Beetlejuice
Sleepy Hollow
Batman Returns
Edward Scissorhands
Pee Wee's Big Adventure
Big Fish

like
Ed Wood
Batman
Charlie & the Chocolate Factory
Nightmare Before Christmas

didn't like
Planet of the Apes
Mars Attacks
Corpse Bride

haven't seen Sweeney Todd but I'm pretty sure i'm going to like it because i think that it's one of the best stories ever.