kittyradio.com



kittyradio.com » real world » news & politics » 17 PINTS in 2 hrs. KILLS pubgoer


Welcome to the kittyradio.com forums.

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. Remove these ads when you register. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-03-2007, 09:39 AM
longshot's Avatar
longshot longshot is offline
stratocaster
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 931
longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts longshot is infamous around these parts
17 PINTS in 2 hrs. KILLS pubgoer

30 May 2007
17 PINTS IN TWO HOURS KILLS STUART
Deadly binge caught on camera
By Marie Sharp
A YOUNG barman died after drinking the equivalent of 17 pints in two hours, an inquiry heard yesterday.
Colleagues of Stuart Foster, 27, didn't call an ambulance after he passed out at the nightclub where he worked. Instead, they took photos of him and poured water over his head.
A workmate took him home in her car but left him in the back seat because she couldn't wake him. She found him dead a few hours later.
Tests showed Stuart had drunk 30 units of alcohol - the equivalent of 17 pints of lager. His blood alcohol levels were more than six times the drink-drive limit and in the range of "fatal poisoning".
Stuart's dad William watched CCTV film of his son's drinking binge yesterday on the first day of a fatal accident inquiry.
At one point, Stuart was seen falling from his seat. His colleagues at Edinburgh's Cavendish nightclub left him on the floor and carried on drinking.

Fellow workers were caught on camera "making a fool of" Stuart by pouring water over him, putting a jacket over his head and taking pictures of him. He didn't react.

The inquiry heard that Stuart, originally from Kelso in the Borders, finished his last shift at the Cavendish at 1.30am on June 11 2004. He then drank with pals until the club closed and carried on drinking after closing time.

The film from the club's security cameras showed him slumped in a chair at around 3.50am, apparently unconscious.

Rachel Simnett, a bar manager at the Cavendish, took Stuart home to her flat. She told police that colleagues helped her put him in her car because he couldn't walk.

Simnett, 28, said she couldn't wake Stuart when she got home and had to leave him in the car. She said she heard a "grunting noise" as she placed a pillow under his head.

At around 11.30am, Simnett and her flatmate found Stuart's body in the car and called 999.

Paramedic Garry Baldie, 47, told the inquiry he had been dead for two or three hours.

The man in charge of the Cavendish that night, senior bar supervisor David Pennycook, 28, told the inquiry he "got it wrong" by failing to call an ambulance.

Pennycook, who now works in financial services, admitted that "with hindsight" he should have got the club's first aider to look at Stuart.

He agreed that he didn't consider how Simnett would get Stuart out of her car once she got him home.

Pennycook had done a course which taught staff how to react if someone was ill through drink.

Fiscal Lesley Thomson told him: "You just sat there and observed Mr Foster being made a fool of and your only involvement was to ensure he was off the premises."

Police inspector Ray Morton, who worked for the licensing board in 2004, told the inquiry no one at the club gave Stuart the help that "could have changed events".

He added: "If Mr Foster was unconscious from alcohol, it is technically a drug overdose. An ambulance should have been called."

The Cavendish had its licence suspended for three months after Stuart's death. It reopened in 2005, renamed Lava and Ignite.

The inquiry at Edinburgh Sheriff Court continues.

SHOUTwire
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-03-2007, 09:44 AM
BleedingHeart's Avatar
BleedingHeart BleedingHeart is offline
Chairman~MouseyTongue
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Chairman Meow
Posts: 6,973
BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute BleedingHeart has a reputation beyond repute
Hate to say but its a society where passing out from drink is normal and often nothing to worry about apparently. No wonder no one saw this coming.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-03-2007, 10:34 AM
knifeyou's Avatar
knifeyou knifeyou is offline
For all the right reasons
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 1,710
knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute knifeyou has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by BleedingHeart View Post
Hate to say but its a society where passing out from drink is normal and often nothing to worry about apparently. No wonder no one saw this coming.
That and you should know your own limits.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 06-03-2007, 12:50 PM
never was's Avatar
never was never was is offline
ya basta
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: shallow grave
Posts: 1,533
never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute never was has a reputation beyond repute
a fresher student died here from alcohol poisoning just before christmas, they found him dead in the street the next morning

what i dont understand is that fair enough, some people dont know their limits, but surely someone would have intervened?
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 06-03-2007, 12:59 PM
larsen's Avatar
larsen larsen is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: the north
Posts: 1,140
larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute
the bar tenders should know when to stop/not serve a customer, even if he isn't buying the drinks they should be keeping a close eye on their customers and the state they're in. pub watch!
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 06-03-2007, 01:01 PM
*^_^*'s Avatar
*^_^* *^_^* is offline
She's like the wind
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Your face.
Posts: 7,013
*^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute *^_^* has a reputation beyond repute
oh sheesh.
Know your limits guys.
I DON'T WANT ANY OF YOU DYING ON ME!
__________________
Diving for pearls.
I want a lolly.

Summer lust, oceans still left to cross.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 06-03-2007, 02:28 PM
Ophiel Ophiuci's Avatar
Ophiel Ophiuci Ophiel Ophiuci is offline
#1 cunt-kicker-in
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Northampton, UK:
Posts: 9,690
Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by larsen View Post
the bar tenders should know when to stop/not serve a customer, even if he isn't buying the drinks they should be keeping a close eye on their customers and the state they're in. pub watch!
Please don't let's do this. Some dude poisons himself by drinking 15 units of alcohol per hour for two hours, and you're saying it's anyone's fault but his?

OK, so after his lack of responsibility for his personal safety, there are others who could have done more. But in terms of negligence, after the main culprit - the dead guy - there's a fucking massive drop-off. Yes, it sucks that we don't have anyone to hold to account. But deal. Let's not start accusing anyone of causing his death unless they actually did/failed to do something that one could reasonably expect to kill someone in a significant number of incidents.

Sorry, the above's a little rambly. But I know how I feel about this.

Also: WHAT A LIGHTWEIGHT.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 06-04-2007, 04:30 PM
XJunkieHeart XJunkieHeart is offline
Post-Rational
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Displaced
Posts: 215
XJunkieHeart is on a distinguished road
What a PUSSY.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 06-04-2007, 04:36 PM
larsen's Avatar
larsen larsen is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: the north
Posts: 1,140
larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ophiel Ophiuci View Post
Please don't let's do this. Some dude poisons himself by drinking 15 units of alcohol per hour for two hours, and you're saying it's anyone's fault but his?

OK, so after his lack of responsibility for his personal safety, there are others who could have done more. But in terms of negligence, after the main culprit - the dead guy - there's a fucking massive drop-off. Yes, it sucks that we don't have anyone to hold to account. But deal. Let's not start accusing anyone of causing his death unless they actually did/failed to do something that one could reasonably expect to kill someone in a significant number of incidents.

Sorry, the above's a little rambly. But I know how I feel about this.

Also: WHAT A LIGHTWEIGHT.
no that's not what i'm saying at all. it think it's totally the guys own fault. it's his body and he should know his limit. i'm just saying bar workers/owners own certain amount of responsibilty for taking care of their customers and if that was done there's a chance he wouldn't have died. unfortunatly there's always some bar that will take you in no matter how intoxicated you are. if not, well he could have gone home and kept on drinking and ended up the same way.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 06-04-2007, 04:39 PM
Ophiel Ophiuci's Avatar
Ophiel Ophiuci Ophiel Ophiuci is offline
#1 cunt-kicker-in
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Northampton, UK:
Posts: 9,690
Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute
It's kinda hard to say "you can't serve people who are drunk". People go to bars to get drunk. How do you decide that, at a certain point, someone is now too drunk? It's not like you can really keep track of how much someone's had, especially if other people are buying them drinks.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 06-04-2007, 04:48 PM
larsen's Avatar
larsen larsen is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: the north
Posts: 1,140
larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ophiel Ophiuci View Post
It's kinda hard to say "you can't serve people who are drunk". People go to bars to get drunk. How do you decide that, at a certain point, someone is now too drunk? It's not like you can really keep track of how much someone's had, especially if other people are buying them drinks.
i've worked in a bar for the past year and had like 100 meetings on this. you just have to judge the best you can on whether somebody has had too much, and it's not really that difficult. unfortunatly there are alot of bar tenders who will serve people who you can just tell have had way too much, either they're completely stupid or just don't want the hassle. some people are fine and understand, others really go off on one. but i for one wouldn't like to have an alcohol related accident on my conscience.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 06-04-2007, 05:12 PM
Ophiel Ophiuci's Avatar
Ophiel Ophiuci Ophiel Ophiuci is offline
#1 cunt-kicker-in
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Northampton, UK:
Posts: 9,690
Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute
But in this instance, since people were buying booze, you might not be so able, particularly if it was busy and if there were several different people doing it.
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 06-04-2007, 05:28 PM
larsen's Avatar
larsen larsen is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: the north
Posts: 1,140
larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ophiel Ophiuci View Post
But in this instance, since people were buying booze, you might not be so able, particularly if it was busy and if there were several different people doing it.
obviously if it was a busy club i'd imagine it would be alot harder but in a bar or a pub even if it's on a busy night you generally take note of the groups and if he was a regular it would be even easier to remember what and how much he's drinking. also if you've got a good team around you that works, you inform each other if you think someone's on their way to becoming intoxicated, if you think they've had too much inform each other to no longer serve them etc. working behind a bar isn't just about getting the drinks out.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 06-04-2007, 05:40 PM
Ophiel Ophiuci's Avatar
Ophiel Ophiuci Ophiel Ophiuci is offline
#1 cunt-kicker-in
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Northampton, UK:
Posts: 9,690
Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute Ophiel Ophiuci has a reputation beyond repute
I know, I just think it's obviously going to be problematic to judge how drunk someone is. I mean, yes, you can tell if someone's drunk, but gaging how drunk is going to be a lot more subjective, surely.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 06-04-2007, 05:54 PM
larsen's Avatar
larsen larsen is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: the north
Posts: 1,140
larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute larsen has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ophiel Ophiuci View Post
I know, I just think it's obviously going to be problematic to judge how drunk someone is. I mean, yes, you can tell if someone's drunk, but gaging how drunk is going to be a lot more subjective, surely.
of course, not everybody reacts the same to alcohol so yeah, it can be difficult. like i said, you just judge it the best you can. if you're unsure, don't serve.
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 06-05-2007, 03:29 AM
VioletPrue's Avatar
VioletPrue VioletPrue is offline
I'm Designer
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: The Netherlands
Posts: 1,766
VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by larsen View Post
obviously if it was a busy club i'd imagine it would be alot harder but in a bar or a pub even if it's on a busy night you generally take note of the groups and if he was a regular it would be even easier to remember what and how much he's drinking. also if you've got a good team around you that works, you inform each other if you think someone's on their way to becoming intoxicated, if you think they've had too much inform each other to no longer serve them etc. working behind a bar isn't just about getting the drinks out.
I'm with you 100%, I worked in a bar too, and this is true.
It can be very, very hard to see if someone has had too much, but some tines you have to be on the safe side of things and just refuse to serve.
I always had a pot of coffee ready around 01:00 AM because that's the time people are getting near the "acceptable drink limit" as I called it.
12:00 if there was a happy hour.
I compare this to taking away a drunks car keys, it's just something you do.
Personal responsibility is the first thing that should be pointed out, but when someone's drunk enough, it goes out the window and others need to step in, beginning with (I would hope) the sober person in the club/pub, the bar tender.
Sometimes people need protection from themselves.
Not only do I think they should have stopped serving him, but not calling an ambulance when someone passes out from drinking and he's not just moaning around, but really, really out of it is criminal IMO.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 06-05-2007, 03:56 AM
carladavvy carladavvy is offline
he who seeks finds
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: ireland
Posts: 283
carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute carladavvy has a reputation beyond repute
i doubt the bar men could really have done much more than they did. The guy drank 30 units in two hours and passed out. The passing out bit is a really regular occurance here in Ireland and i myself am idiotic enough to have done it more than i care to admit. Each time though the bar men and the bouncers just remove you from the club and leave you on the street, with or without your friends!!!
It's nobody's fault but the persnon who drank too much! but the bar men never seem to take into account the fact that a person's drink may have been spiked etc.
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 06-05-2007, 05:02 AM
VioletPrue's Avatar
VioletPrue VioletPrue is offline
I'm Designer
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: The Netherlands
Posts: 1,766
VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute VioletPrue has a reputation beyond repute
^^ Throwing a passed out person on he street after YOU sold them the alcohol?
That should be criminal negligence IMO.
It's selling a product you KNOW can cause harm, and when the person does harm themselves you leave them to get mugged/get raped/die.
I can't understand how someone would just chuck another person unconscious on the street.
At least call the cops or something to make sure they are okay.
When you sell someone alcohol you are partially responsible for them.
If you give them 6 times the legal DUI limit, you are very, very responsible for them.
A bartender KNOWS that 6 times the DUI limit can be fatal, they seriously should have monitored better.
As I read the article, the alcohol was served AFTER the club closed, so it wasn't busy, they could have known he was drinking too much.
It was a colleague of theirs right?
It wasn't a random costumer they couldn't keep track of because it was too busy, he was drinking with colleagues.
This is awful, and yes, again, he shouldn't have been drinking that much, but they share responsibility in this.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 06-05-2007, 05:12 AM
bort's Avatar
bort bort is offline
Phil Goff
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Westport, New Zealand
Posts: 18,437
bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute
KNOW YOUR LIMITZ. Especially if you can't hold your liquor.
__________________
Time is the distance that you can't return by miles.

I escaped somehow. Let's go

actualy [sic] I have quite a blessed life if I'm honest. I have many people to love, hate few and have few money problem's [sic].... What more does a person need? Oh yeah and I have some kind of humbleness unlike you of course ^_^ ~ CarefulCarpenter
Reply With Quote