UMM, Billy Corgan has officially replaced Jimmy Chamberlin with a 19 year old kid. - Page 4

bort · #16 08-18-2009, 12:02 PM

Everybody say oopalot!

debaser · #17 08-18-2009, 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wizard

who cares? the smashing pumpkins IS billy. nobody cares about jimmy, james, d'arcy, or melissa.

out of them all, Billy's solo album is better than jimmy's (which i like), james' (which is so christian and awful it is not even funny) and melissa's (so ****ed up but some moments are okay) and d'arcy is lame and doesn't even have anything to show for herself. it's kinda obvious that only one of these people is for real!

first of all, billy's solo record BLOWS much like anyhting SP released since 1995!

second of all, melissa was ONLY a TOURING member of the smashing pumpkins. she DID NOT record with them, so why have her on the list?

debaser · #18 08-18-2009, 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by earthcrosser75

I think if Billy's songwriting alone could carry a band, he would have put out a solo album with at least one listenable song on it.

word

wizard · #19 08-19-2009, 01:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by earthcrosser75

I think if Billy's songwriting alone could carry a band, he would have put out a solo album with at least one listenable song on it. and did you ever read anything from blinking with fists?

um billy's solo album is actually quite good. sorry but i like it when people change up their career and don't get stuck in some ****ty rut like nina gordon your favorite musician ever and also quite possibly the second biggest loser in music besides her fat ex girlfriend louise. also blinking with fists was a risk and if an artists doesn't take risks then what are they doing?

wizard · #20 08-19-2009, 01:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by debaser

first of all, billy's solo record BLOWS much like anyhting SP released since 1995!

second of all, melissa was ONLY a TOURING member of the smashing pumpkins. she DID NOT record with them, so why have her on the list?

lol. like james and d'arcy actually recorded with the band. that's why mel made the list, becuz billy is the pumpkins and any true fan knows that. and i think all their work post 1995 is incredible and underrated. i'm glad a lame brain retard like you doesn't get ADORE. it's for people with a soul.