kittyradio.com



kittyradio.com » listen & watch » the jukebox » xtina vs mimi


Welcome to the kittyradio.com forums.

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. Remove these ads when you register. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
View Poll Results: just one.
mariah 17 36.17%
xtina 30 63.83%
Voters: 47. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
LinkBack (2) Thread Tools Display Modes
  2 links from elsewhere to this Post. Click to view. #1  
Old 05-10-2008, 04:12 PM
l'avatar's Avatar
l'avatar l'avatar is offline
hi hater.
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 2,634
l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute
Exclamation xtina vs mimi

apparently they're comparable?

mariah carey or christina aguilera. two answers. no cute stuff. i just wanna know who you would choose. judge by w/e you want. looks/talent/songs/idc.

or if its the case, the one you'd least likely punch.

just so i sleep well at nite.

thx.

o, & this is a nice little note-by-note review.

ERROR: If you can see this, then YouTube is down or you don't have Flash installed.

__________________
three
line
sig
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 05-10-2008, 04:34 PM
EMMAh's Avatar
EMMAh EMMAh is offline
< :3 )~~~
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Canafuckinda
Posts: 4,311
EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute EMMAh has a reputation beyond repute
I say Christina, just because I liked her as a child and I've never liked anything Maria has put out.
__________________
I have to leave somehow
Before they run me out of town
I have to leave somehow
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 05-10-2008, 04:39 PM
CrackneyLove's Avatar
CrackneyLove CrackneyLove is offline
Crackbabble
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Brazil Indiana
Posts: 665
CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute
Christina by a mile. I really don't understand Mariah Carey.

Did anyone see the Saturday Night Live episode where Christina is singing her signature, Linda Perry, written song Beautiful totally accapella? It was amazing. That's all I can say, it left me speechless.

Last edited by CrackneyLove : 05-10-2008 at 09:19 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 05-10-2008, 04:40 PM
catatonicx's Avatar
catatonicx catatonicx is online now
hey goo, whats new?
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: it varies.
Posts: 1,383
catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute catatonicx has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by EMMAh View Post
I say Christina, just because I liked her as a child and I've never liked anything Maria has put out.
same.
__________________
can't live for tomorrow
tomorrow's much too long.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 05-10-2008, 05:39 PM
vanitykills's Avatar
vanitykills vanitykills is offline
sexual chocolate, baby!
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: lost
Posts: 2,283
vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute vanitykills has a reputation beyond repute
mariah, shes earned her status, and shes been around longer.
__________________
myspace.com/skimberlee
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 05-10-2008, 05:45 PM
fuck me fred fuck me fred is offline
cletus+inga friends 4evR
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 1,107
fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute fuck me fred has a reputation beyond repute
I think Mariah's fans must be a bunch of jocko dykes, because the way they judge art is a little alarming.

She can hit the most notes, so she must be the best!!! They can't wrap their track & field mentalities around the fact that isn't the case.

I realize this isn't the fag feud in question, but Madonna pulls off a song like "Live to Tell" despite her limited vocals. Mariah has made a career of over-emoting and wouldn't know subtlety if it grew watermelon sized and lodged itself in her fish pit.

I vote for Christina. Sort of by default, but also because I've liked a few of her singles.

Some of my worst memories from elementary school involve having "Hero" played at year end assemblies. No idea who's bright idea that was, but I'm sure she was fat.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 05-10-2008, 09:22 PM
bort's Avatar
bort bort is offline
Phil Goff
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Westport, New Zealand
Posts: 17,822
bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute
Christina smells of Linda Perry. Courtney is enough for me, I don't need Chrissie to do it as well.
__________________
"She blackens my name in the press and makes me think abortion is an excellent idea"

Time is the distance that you can't return by miles.

"I escaped somehow. Let's go"

actualy [sic] I have quite a blessed life if I'm honest. I have many people to love, hate few and have few money problem's [sic].... What more does a person need? Oh yeah and I have some kind of humbleness unlike you of course ^_^ ~ CarefulCarpenter
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 05-10-2008, 09:24 PM
CrackneyLove's Avatar
CrackneyLove CrackneyLove is offline
Crackbabble
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Brazil Indiana
Posts: 665
CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute CrackneyLove has a reputation beyond repute
What is wrong with Linda Perry? Linda Perry is pretty fuckin' awesome...she also has an amazing voice as well.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 05-10-2008, 09:27 PM
Red Cloud Red Cloud is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Home
Posts: 7
Red Cloud is an unknown quantity at this point
neither,.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 05-11-2008, 01:44 AM
Mother Greer's Avatar
Mother Greer Mother Greer is offline
crown and anchor me
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 3,722
Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute Mother Greer has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by fuck me fred View Post
Mariah has made a career of over-emoting and wouldn't know subtlety if it grew watermelon sized and lodged itself in her fish pit.
that's not true though? i can understand why someone would think that from just listening to the singles, but if you hear songs like "looking in", it's pretty obvious that she CAN sing without the over-the-top vocals.

i picked mariah cos i've always loved her hahah but i like christina as well. they are fo shiz my guilty pleasure music.
__________________
It doesn't matter what country someone's from, or what they look like, or the colour of their skin. It doesn't matter what they smell like, or that they spell words slightly differently, some would say more correctly. I'm a person. Bret's a person. You're a person. That person over there is a person. And each person deserves to be treated like a person.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 05-11-2008, 03:54 AM
desdemona's Avatar
desdemona desdemona is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Ireland
Posts: 1,705
desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute desdemona has a reputation beyond repute
Christina, although Mariah is a class singer too but in a way that you just know she spent her whole life with singing coaches. Xtina's got a voice of her own.
__________________
I like the peace in the back seat
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 05-11-2008, 05:43 AM
indigenousinsight's Avatar
indigenousinsight indigenousinsight is offline
bohemian artisan
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: bright lights...big city
Posts: 1,591
indigenousinsight has disabled reputation
if i had to choose id say xtina for fighter is the best pop song from a pop artist in recent yrs and i have all 3 of her cds-fave tracks-fighter,im ok,make over,get mine get yours,genie in a bottle,back in the day,candyman,here to stay,dirty,still dirty,the voice within,reflection,soar,aint no other man,what a girl wants,and i turn to you.....(mariah and sheryl crow were most consistent 90s sinles artists with memorable singalongy decent stuff)now mariah i like alot too although i wish shed drop those dumb ass rappers and think shes delusional when she says she thinks they add to her songs like the fantasy version with odb is better then one witout him wtf i loathe her new song touch my body and the vocal is prolly her worst vocal ever not to mention dumb song i always liked her singles and never bought an album although every album had memorable ones (fantastic ones)then she had duds like the roof and heartbreaker and that new song ...cringe....anyways her hits collection is ace,charmbracelet isnt amazing,and emancipation is decent mainly for we belong together,and shake it off is good too as for favorite tracks.....my all,one sweet day,fantasy,dreamlover,emotions,vision of love,we belong together,forever,i dont wanna cry,love takes time,hero,make it happen,cant let go,when you believe,and without you.marah writes alot of her own stuff and emotes it to her fullest extent of knowing how to express it and i dont find her to be a total showoff.i think they are two of the best singers in the world too and i think mariah is a better singer then xtina however i think xtina is better then celine by a mile as is monica,and toni braxton so i dont know how people say (american idol and others)that 3 best singers are mariah,whitney,and celine.however whitney houston is the best singer of the modern era period or atlest she was before the crack and i hope she still has it.i know off topic but nobody in randb nowadays comes close to the amazing whitney tracks all at once,saving all my love for you,where do broken hearts go,one moment in time,didnt we almost have it all,i have nothing,run to you,my love is your love,i will always love you.i always find it laughable when one tries to compare mary j blige or alicia keys to the unbeatable whitney for whitneys voice is pure and powerful and perfect and wow.i was just listening to whitney last night as a matter of fact.now whitneys are true anthems and i feel no one gives whitney her due and pays enough respect to her nowadays and admit it she is the most talented singer who dont write her material and she emotes gorgeously and lastly none of those american idol people come close to whitney.so not to sabotage the thread but show whitney some love too.
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 05-11-2008, 06:34 AM
dollie_midget's Avatar
dollie_midget dollie_midget is offline
old gregg?
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 1,053
dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute dollie_midget has a reputation beyond repute
Christina has more than 3 albums.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 05-11-2008, 06:51 AM
bort's Avatar
bort bort is offline
Phil Goff
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Westport, New Zealand
Posts: 17,822
bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute bort has a reputation beyond repute
I have to say, Mariah's version of "Bringing on the Heartbreak" [Def Leppard original] won it for me. She's done more utter bilge than Christina, but she's done more bearable stuff as well. Just more of everything, including entertaining breakdowns, and videos with fat kids on rollerblades. Not that I actually like either much.

Once, my friend's car got broken into when she was down on the beach. For some reason, the only thing taken was a CD of Mariah Carey's MTV Unplugged that I had bought her for about three bucks. Gutting.


edit due to tardness
__________________
"She blackens my name in the press and makes me think abortion is an excellent idea"

Time is the distance that you can't return by miles.

"I escaped somehow. Let's go"

actualy [sic] I have quite a blessed life if I'm honest. I have many people to love, hate few and have few money problem's [sic].... What more does a person need? Oh yeah and I have some kind of humbleness unlike you of course ^_^ ~ CarefulCarpenter

Last edited by bort : 05-12-2008 at 06:19 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 05-11-2008, 01:27 PM
l'avatar's Avatar
l'avatar l'avatar is offline
hi hater.
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 2,634
l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute
i have to say that "bringing on the heartbreak" was pretty phenomenal for me. it really is by far the best cover she's done. which was surprising, because i take my 80's stripper jams very seriously. i could've done without the video though.

& when it comes to whitney, i've never really thought much of her vocally. i think her voice kind've trite & boring. sure she can belt & hold a note, but other than that, she's just so bland. & i've never actually been able to like her songs, sans the Bodyguard OST. & when people compared whitney to mariah, i always wondered why, seeing as whitney's voice is just so basic & mariah's is just so much more.

when it comes down it, mariah has more talent than whitney can smoke. & that's that.
__________________
three
line
sig
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 05-11-2008, 01:40 PM
inferior wine's Avatar
inferior wine inferior wine is offline
Go team!
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Bucharest, Romania
Posts: 356
inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute inferior wine has a reputation beyond repute
I don't actually like either of them, but Christina's voice sounds better.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 05-11-2008, 02:36 PM
Black Mambo's Avatar
Black Mambo Black Mambo is offline
give me sweet, sweet soul
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Scotland
Posts: 4,204
Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute Black Mambo has a reputation beyond repute
I mean, I just got led from that youtube to another of Mariah which had showed parts of her range from A2 to F7.

And I thought, is there any need for anybody to be singing a F7? It doesn't even sound good. It adds nothing to the song. It's just squealing for the sake of it.
__________________
Deux hommes font une promenade amicale. L'un des deux porte un parapluie à son bras.
Il se met à pleuvoir. L'homme n'ouvre pas son parapluie et l'autre lui demande pourquoi.
- Parce que ça ne servirait à rien, lui répond son ami. Il est plein de trous.
- Alors, pourquoi l'as-tu pris?
- Parce que je ne pensais pas qu'il pleuvrait.
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 05-11-2008, 04:30 PM
hey hey is offline
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 131
hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute hey has a reputation beyond repute
Christina.
Not a huge fan of either, but I liked a couple of Christinas songs.

When Mariah sings hero or without you..whatever. She just really overdoes the wailing on those. And her song Touch my body is an insipid wank.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 05-11-2008, 10:18 PM
PompousCunt's Avatar
PompousCunt PompousCunt is offline
.........................
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: London, UK
Posts: 2,630
PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute PompousCunt has a reputation beyond repute
Hmmm, dunno. Like bits of the both of them so I'm not gonna pick, but if were talking looks, Mariah wins. Now, could someone please upload her version of "Bringin' On The Heartbreak". I hadn't even heard it until I just youtubed. Lol at 'The Rose' inspired video though.

ERROR: If you can see this, then YouTube is down or you don't have Flash installed.
__________________
We can make love, but do not touch my face or my hair.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 05-11-2008, 11:38 PM
l'avatar's Avatar
l'avatar l'avatar is offline
hi hater.
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 2,634
l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute l'avatar has a reputation beyond repute