OFFICIAL: Madonna CANNOT sing live? - Page 3

HighClassHo · #11 06-30-2006, 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yesterdayscokebuzz

Not to be a bitch, but I watched the clip to see what all the hoopla was about, and no...she can't sing. Did you really listen?? Her pitch is off and her voice wavers. Granted, she is a package thats sold...a performer in every way, but a truly gifted vocalist? No...she is not.

she is not a truly gifted vocalist but she is not someone who can't reach a note even if it depended on her life, like everyone says. She can sing.

yesterdayscokebuzz · #12 06-30-2006, 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HighClassHo

she is not a truly gifted vocalist but she is not someone who can't reach a note even if it depended on her life, like everyone says. She can sing.

Well, I never said she couldn't hit a note. She can carry a tune, true...but you're claiming her vocals in said performance to be "amazing", which they are not.

HighClassHo · #13 06-30-2006, 02:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yesterdayscokebuzz

Well, I never said she couldn't hit a note. She can carry a tune, true...but you're claiming her vocals in said performance to be "amazing", which they are not.

I talk like that. I embellish everything I say, I don't know why, lol. All I'm saying is she has a decent voice and she can sing. You don't need to be Mariah to be a good singer, I think Madonna is a good singer.

kfpandas · #14 06-30-2006, 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HighClassHo

seeing that video reminded me exactly why I hate Christina Aguilera. Not only is she hideous but she makes a horrible Marilyn. Marilyn was about class and honest sexuality/sensuality. Christina is trash and her sensuality/sexuality is so fake and contrived it's everything but sexy. And she's 16 years late, Madonna already did everything she's doing now with her I'm Breathless album.

I really don't think Christina's trying to be the new Madonna. I hate her Marilyn Monroe act, too, but at least the girl can fucking sing. She may not be quite the performer Madonna is, but Jesus the girl has talent.

aaron · #15 06-30-2006, 03:19 PM

bryan have you seen the bonus scenes on "i'm going to tell you a secret"?

she can totally sing in one of them.