Quote:
Originally Posted by klimt .. and sorry, but you can't blame your parents for who you are as a person after your 30th birthday. Then it's all up to you to be who you are.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Black Mambo She's had her many ups and downs, and perhaps her earlier falls could be fairly attributed to her hopeless upbringing, but there should have come a time when she ought to have figured everything out herself, especially after having become a parent. If she can assert that she's "nobody's daughter", she also has to take responsibility for her own failures. |
I do agree with all of that, I just don't think Hank and Linda should get to complain about her (everyone else can). And I guess I also subscribe to some sort of paralell responsibility theory - while I agree that
Courtney is too old to blame her shitty upbringing for the way she is, I feel Linda and Hank didn't stop being respsonsble for how they failed her either. It's not either/or for me. They started her off at a serious disadvantage in terms of her chances to become a healthy sane adult. She should have taken responsibility for doing whatever she needed to do to overcome that, especially when she chose to become a parent herself, and she did not. They're all at fault. But, at the risk of sounding like a five year old, they started it. The fact that
Courtney isn't entitled to use her parents as an an excuse for what she does at this point doesn't mean they don't deserve any blame, and it doesn't change the fact that she likely would have been different if properly parented. It's not a zero-sum game.
Hank, especially annoys me (I didn't see this show, I'm going on other things I've seen), because it's so obvious with him that what bothers him is
not the many things wrong with
Courtney but the fact that he didn't get in on her gravy train. If he could have gotten access to the Nirvana money, if he could have been featured in a 1995
People magazine spread with staged pictures of him playing with little Frances and sappy bullshit text about how he reconciled with his daughter in her time of need to help with his fatherless grandchild, I don't think he would have turned any of this down on the basis that
Courtney is an unstable bitch. If
Courtney had done what she needed to do, dealt with her issues, not blamed everyone but herself for what she does, not fucked her head further with drugs, it still probably wouldn't be advisable for her to have him in her life. I think he would be every bit as angry at her in that case. He got lucky, really, that she didn't do that, because this way he has a pre-built market to sell all his 'Look how fucked up my kid is! stories.