kittyradio.com



kittyradio.com » mind, body, & soul » diet & exercise » VEGETARIAN Vs. MEAT EATER Weight Loss?


Welcome to the kittyradio.com forums.

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. Remove these ads when you register. By joining our free community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old 08-15-2007, 03:08 AM
Hanoi J's Avatar
Hanoi J Hanoi J is offline
Thoroughbred
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 146
Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by dirtyplotte View Post
small amounts are ok, but if you eat a potato alone you are dumping sugar straight into your blood stream. french fries are better for you in that sense, than is a plain blaked potato.
no.

Calories in Potato, Baked, Flesh And Skin

fried foods aren't much easier on the body...

Calories in French Fries

Last edited by Hanoi J : 08-15-2007 at 03:28 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:10 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by aura View Post
i understand that you are a nurse and are trained to know more about this sort of stuff than me, but

french fries > baked potato?

how is that possible?

and, i keep reading conflicting reports.
because the fat slows the uptake of the sugars. if youre a diabetic, and you have a choice between french fries and baked potato as a meal, always pick the french fries,.

but really, you shouldnt pick either.
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:11 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hanoi J View Post
no.

Calories in Potato, Baked, Flesh And Skin

fried foods aren't much easier on the body...

Calories in French Fries
uhhh its not about the calories? its baout your body getting too much sugar at once and insulin dumping that follows.

nutrition is more than just calories people!
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:15 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by aura View Post
this report is about diabetics losing weight in order to beat diabetes and high carb vs low carb in order to lose wight, not about insulin dumping and how that causes diabetes type II.
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:24 AM
Hanoi J's Avatar
Hanoi J Hanoi J is offline
Thoroughbred
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 146
Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute Hanoi J has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by dirtyplotte View Post
uhhh its not about the calories? its baout your body getting too much sugar at once and insulin dumping that follows.

nutrition is more than just calories people!
Yes, which is why they are full "nutrition facts" and not just a number; click the links next time.
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:34 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hanoi J View Post
Yes, which is why they are full "nutrition facts" and not just a number; click the links next time.
again youre not getting it. its not about the amount of "nutrition" that is at question here. its the glycemic load. which causes insulin dumping, which causes insulin resistance which leads to diabetes. its how people develop diabetes.

here is a primer on glycemic index
Glycemic index - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:42 AM
kesh's Avatar
kesh kesh is offline
be still, cody
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: port-au-patois
Posts: 9,560
kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute kesh has a reputation beyond repute
a doctor writes:

if you can you should swallow potatoes whole, that way your salivary amylase doesn't get a chance to break them down. any sugar rush will be dependent on pancreatic amylase, which you can inhibit by giving yourself chronic pancreatitis through a lifetime of excess alcohol consumption
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:43 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
the insulin index is much newer and not as well researched but promising of coure. and in that, the only thing higher than the baked potato is jellybeans. potato is not your friend if youre a diabetic, or if youre at risk for diabetes.

Insulin Index
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #29  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:43 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by kesh View Post
a doctor writes:

if you can you should swallow potatoes whole, that way your salivary amylase doesn't get a chance to break them down. any sugar rush will be dependent on pancreatic amylase, which you can inhibit by giving yourself chronic pancreatitis through a lifetime of excess alcohol consumption

im trying to imagine swallowing a whole potato

nad a general lollerskates here. <3
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #30  
Old 08-15-2007, 10:38 PM
herekitty's Avatar
herekitty herekitty is offline
Occam's chainsaw
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: goin down in a blaze of glory
Posts: 7,072
herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by kesh View Post
a doctor writes:

if you can you should swallow potatoes whole, that way your salivary amylase doesn't get a chance to break them down. any sugar rush will be dependent on pancreatic amylase, which you can inhibit by giving yourself chronic pancreatitis through a lifetime of excess alcohol consumption
this sounds like an excellent health plan. Although I need to know if drinking vodka will undo all of the benefits of being an alcoholic?

Quote:
Originally Posted by dirtyplotte View Post
the insulin index is much newer and not as well researched but promising of coure. and in that, the only thing higher than the baked potato is jellybeans. potato is not your friend if youre a diabetic, or if youre at risk for diabetes.

Insulin Index
this is crazy to me. how can foods that are just plain sugar be less damaging than a potato? It would make more sense if the jelly beans weren't the exception. I'm so freakin glad I'm not diabetic. I've been having an intense craving for potatoes for the last couple of days. I guess I shouldn't have too many or I could become diabetic.

Quote:
Originally Posted by dirtyplotte View Post
im trying to imagine swallowing a whole potato
yes, I'm thinking those little "new"/red potatoes. Kesh, I need to know if the little ones will work. please find out from your source.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sophia_ View Post
my wife called me an asshole ~~carefulcarpenter
Reply With Quote
  #31  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:32 PM
bodah's Avatar
bodah bodah is offline
stirred... rarely shaken
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Northwest
Posts: 599
bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute bodah has a reputation beyond repute
Hey, I was a vegetarian for about 6 months. It sounds like a feelble run but I tried & was hungry all the time. A few years later, I got pregnant & gained 60 pounds which was mortifying because prior to that I'd always been in shape through a well-balanced diet, moderation, & exercise. One way I lost the weight -- besides exercise --- was on the advice from my MD who said that Atkins "works". I don't do it anymore but I learned from that experience. 1: it's a myth that your cholesterol goes up. Mine remained unchanged, and I ate less because protein fills you up & sends messages to your brain that you're full. 2: I was never anemic despite a prior history of anemia. 3: All of my weight came off. 4: One BIZARRE side effect: I NEVER (not even once) had any gas. No kidding; I never farted on a high protein diet. So I'm with you on the zero bloating. Also, my skin & hair were goregous.

I think it's great for people to be vegetarian for spiritual reasons, but I even though other primates are herbivores, I don't humans evolved that way. There's scientific history to show (despite the argument that our jaws are supposedly smaller & therefore we're not intended to eat meat) that our species has been hunter/gatherer for far longer (20,000plus?) than agriculturally-oriented (8000 yrs?). Meat, fish, eggs, berries, greens = what we were meant to eat. Bread, sugar, & processed foods (even whole wheat flour is a processed food because it takes a beating from its form in nature to be ground into flour) are the root of most of our dietary evil. They are a modern dietary invention. Heavily processed food is even newer

Since I've limited processed food & sugar, I've never been healthier or at a better weight in my entire life. I only have cravings & overeat when I vary from that routine. But I also don't eat animal proteins that are high in saturated fats often; for me it's mostly fish & fowl.

Consuming proteins helps you maintain lean muscle mass. Lean mass means higher metabolism. I lift weights, exercise 6 days a week, eat about 2000 calories a day (with occasional days of 2500) without gaining any weight.
Reply With Quote
  #32  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:43 PM
recalcitrant's Avatar
recalcitrant recalcitrant is offline
Cherry Kookoo
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: inside glammy's head
Posts: 2,293
recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute
if i were you, i'd be introducing meat SLOWLY into your diet you have been a veggie for a long time and so the intestinal flora in your stomach would be geared for mainly veggie food and not to decompose meat, which lives in teh intestines a lot longer than veggies/legumes.

i'd also make it very small servings as well (eg a warm lamb salad, thinly sliced, type thing)

i'd also be getting organic, hormone GM free (eg the animals weren't eating grain that has GM product in it) meat as well. you dont' want growth hormones and nasties in your system

also as a veggo you do have protein, its just a matter of combining them as its non-heme form
eg baked beans on wholeweath toast. yes its processed but its still healthier than a lot of other things, like eating saturate fat from meat
or i have a dahl and rice (if i can, brown rice)
or veggies and rice/noodles
it can still be healthy.

Last edited by recalcitrant : 08-15-2007 at 11:52 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #33  
Old 08-15-2007, 11:46 PM
recalcitrant's Avatar
recalcitrant recalcitrant is offline
Cherry Kookoo
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: inside glammy's head
Posts: 2,293
recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute recalcitrant has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by dirtyplotte View Post
small amounts are ok, but if you eat a potato alone you are dumping sugar straight into your blood stream. french fries are better for you in that sense, than is a plain blaked potato.
you'd have to be a nutter to eat plain baked potato...not when tehre is
corn
sour cream
baked beans
butter
garlic/herb butter
to eat with it
;-)
Reply With Quote
  #34  
Old 08-16-2007, 12:11 AM
herekitty's Avatar
herekitty herekitty is offline
Occam's chainsaw
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: goin down in a blaze of glory
Posts: 7,072
herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute herekitty has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by bodah View Post
Hey, I was a vegetarian for about 6 months. It sounds like a feelble run but I tried & was hungry all the time.
did it ever occur to you that you were doing it wrong? I mean I realize not everyone is cut out to be a vegetarian but did you even consider that possibility?

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodah View Post
1: it's a myth that your cholesterol goes up. Mine remained unchanged,
You are not every person. Your experiences with this don't mean that on average, other people's cholesterol didn't increase. just as my positive experience with vegetarianism doesn't mean everyone has that.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodah View Post
2: I was never anemic despite a prior history of anemia.
Did anyone here suggest that eating too much protein would cause anemia, cos I must have missed that?


Quote:
Originally Posted by bodah View Post
There's scientific history to show (despite the argument that our jaws are supposedly smaller & therefore we're not intended to eat meat) that our species has been hunter/gatherer for far longer (20,000plus?) than agriculturally-oriented (8000 yrs?).
the jaw is not the reason people believe we've evolved to eat mostly plants- it's the teeth. the molars specifically. the cusps are for grinding grains and veggies, etc. our "canines" are rather pathetic and we can barely pierce insects with those pitiful little things. if you want to see a real carnivore's teeth, look in the mouth of a cat.

btw, we've been evolving for millions of years now, 20,000 years is nothing.

Quote:
Originally Posted by bodah View Post
Meat, fish, eggs, berries, greens = what we were meant to eat. Bread, sugar, & processed foods (even whole wheat flour is a processed food because it takes a beating from its form in nature to be ground into flour) are the root of most of our dietary evil. They are a modern dietary invention. Heavily processed food is even newer
no, we really weren't meant to eat meat or fish but the second part of this is definitely onto something. the fact is we were much healthier as hunter/gatherers but there were other factors involved that made it so. (1) We were getting a variety of foods in our diet, not the same things over and over again. (2) we kept away from our waste and also avoided diseases that occur when people are crowded into close quarters with each other. meat may or may not have had something to do with it.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sophia_ View Post
my wife called me an asshole ~~carefulcarpenter
Reply With Quote
  #35  
Old 08-16-2007, 06:46 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by recalcitrant View Post
you'd have to be a nutter to eat plain baked potato...not when tehre is
corn
sour cream
baked beans
butter
garlic/herb butter
to eat with it
;-)
<3 agreed.

i dont know the glycemic loading with a fully loaded potato. im sure someone has measured it. make public those results please!
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #36  
Old 08-16-2007, 06:50 AM
dirtyplotte's Avatar
dirtyplotte dirtyplotte is offline
give me the sickest one.
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: fox in the snow
Posts: 7,753
dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute dirtyplotte has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by recalcitrant View Post

i'd also make it very small servings as well (eg a warm lamb salad, thinly sliced, type thing)

ok so even if i ever went back to eating mammals, which i dont think i ever will, i could never, not in ten thousand gazillion years eat LAMB SALAD. who the fuck eats lamb other than my sick freak fuck step monster?

silence the screaming of teh lambZ
__________________
When I awoke, the Dire Wolf
Six hundred pounds of sin
Was grinning at my window
All I said was "Come on in".
Grateful Dead
Reply With Quote
  #37  
Old 08-16-2007, 07:48 AM